Details about the paper
Reviewer:
Type of the paper:
Date of submission:
Title of the paper:
Authors:
Acceptance date of the reviewer to make review:
Date of return of the reviewer:
Recommendation
- To Accept for publication
- Accept with minor changes
- Accept with major changes
- To reject
Type of paper
- Original scientific paper
- Review
- Else:
Do you want to receive the paper again, after corrections of the text by the author?
- Yes
- No
COMMENTS
Confidential comments to the Editor in Chief
1. General comments on paper
2. Detailed comments
Page X, Paragraph XX, Line XXX
Comments for the authors
This section should contain the following elements:
1. General comments on paper
2. Detailed comments
2.1 Summary
Page X, Paragraph XX, Line XXX
2.2 Introduction
Page X, Paragraph XX, Line XXX
2.3 Material and Method
Page X, Paragraph XX, Line XXX
2.4 Results
Page X, Paragraph XX, Line XXX
2.5 Discussion
Page X, Paragraph XX, Line XXX
2.6 Conclusion/Findings
Page X, Paragraph XX, Line XXX
Within each of these chapters comments and suggestions corrections given in the following form:
- Page X, paragraph XX, XXX line (eg, p. 2., Para. 3, line 45)
Attached documents:
- If you're doing a review in a document (Word, WordPad, etc..), please provide the name of the attached file: